Skip to content

Case study · Professional services

SeniorLeads: 69 retirement leads at $9.66 each

SeniorLeads, a US retirement financial advisory, needed retirement-ready leads without paying the premium costs common in financial services advertising. We targeted cruise and travel enthusiasts aged 50–65+ and tested four messaging angles side by side using Facebook lead forms. In April 2022 the account generated 69 leads at an average of $9.66, with the best campaign at $7.70.

Leads in April
69
Average cost per lead
$9.66
Best campaign cost per lead
$7.70
Total account spend
$700

The client

SeniorLeads is a US retirement financial advisory. They needed qualified leads: people in or near retirement, with disposable income, who would consider an annuity product.

The challenge

  • Broad “retirement” audiences on Facebook are saturated with insurance, banking and annuity advertisers, which pushes costs up.
  • Industry average cost per lead for financial services Facebook ads was $15–$25 (WordStream 2022 benchmarks).
  • We had to find the right people without paying the premium that comes with obvious financial-services targeting.

What we did

  • Affinity targeting: instead of “retirement” interests, we targeted cruise and travel enthusiasts aged 50–65+. Cruise passengers skew towards retirement age, have disposable income and are overlooked by financial advertisers.
  • Four-angle test: four campaigns ran at the same time, each with its own budget, testing Social Security income, mutual funds, rollover/job change and retirement lifestyle messages.
  • Facebook Instant Forms instead of a landing page, pre-filling name, email and phone to cut form abandonment.
  • A traffic campaign and a website purchase campaign ran alongside to build a retargeting pool.

Results

  • 69 leads across the four lead campaigns from 15,516 impressions and 10,027 people reached.
  • $9.66 average cost per lead, from a total account spend of $700 for 1–30 April 2022.
  • Retirement lifestyle (“What Would You Do with More Retirement Income?”): 22 leads at $7.70.
  • Social Security income: 18 leads at $8.92.
  • Rollover/job change: 18 leads at $9.51.
  • Mutual funds: 11 leads at $15.02, cut early.

What we learned

  • Lifestyle income messaging beat every product-specific angle; the mutual funds angle cost 2× more per lead.
  • On-Facebook lead forms remove landing-page friction for trust-heavy financial products.
  • Separate campaigns per angle give clean data on what to scale and what to cut.

More results

Related case studies

Want results like these?

Start with a free ROI audit. We'll show you what's possible for your business.